lets all have a disco wrote:If Bobby doesnt win a pot this year i'd be happy to see Pep arrive.
There i've said it.
Chinners wrote:Pep wouldn't just be new to managing in England, he would be new to managing any other club in the world other than Barcelona ... thats my concern tbh. I'm very happy for Mancini to cointinue at the moment no matter what happens this season (as long as we get a top 2 position obv.)
Ted Hughes wrote:Chinners wrote:Pep wouldn't just be new to managing in England, he would be new to managing any other club in the world other than Barcelona ... thats my concern tbh. I'm very happy for Mancini to cointinue at the moment no matter what happens this season (as long as we get a top 2 position obv.)
From a Premier League perspective it would be a huge gamble.
From an academy perspective, it would be a gamble to let him go to Utd, Arsenal or Chelsea, as he knows how it all works & is quite capable of putting at least a small spanner in the works regarding our plans.
Chinners wrote:Ted Hughes wrote:Chinners wrote:Pep wouldn't just be new to managing in England, he would be new to managing any other club in the world other than Barcelona ... thats my concern tbh. I'm very happy for Mancini to cointinue at the moment no matter what happens this season (as long as we get a top 2 position obv.)
From a Premier League perspective it would be a huge gamble.
From an academy perspective, it would be a gamble to let him go to Utd, Arsenal or Chelsea, as he knows how it all works & is quite capable of putting at least a small spanner in the works regarding our plans.
Oh yeah, I'd have him as Academy coach, no probs
Ted Hughes wrote:Why is it that, when this subject crops up, a load of people turn into morons ? Fucking grow up.
It's a perfectly reasonable subject for discussion. Pep has just said he wants to be a manager in England.
I think Mancini has a better chance of achieving short term, continued success than Guardiola, as he has already done it & would have certainly done it again this season if he'd been allowed to sign RVP. The fact that the club had no enthusiasm for signing RVP should be an indication of the possible area where City, & Mancini could be at odds in their thinking.
If people weren't so busy happily slaughtering Marwood & had a bit of nous, they would notice this. Do you all really think that Soriano etc had no input ? They just suddenly blundered into the job in a state of total surprise & shock trying to rectify the mistakes of the evil Marwood ?
City have a plan. Not just for now, but for decades to come. If they feel Mancini is the right bloke to take that forward, he will be in charge for a long time. If they think Pep is a better choice, Bob will be gone.
Hazy2 wrote:Ted Hughes wrote:Why is it that, when this subject crops up, a load of people turn into morons ? Fucking grow up.
It's a perfectly reasonable subject for discussion. Pep has just said he wants to be a manager in England.
I think Mancini has a better chance of achieving short term, continued success than Guardiola, as he has already done it & would have certainly done it again this season if he'd been allowed to sign RVP. The fact that the club had no enthusiasm for signing RVP should be an indication of the possible area where City, & Mancini could be at odds in their thinking.
If people weren't so busy happily slaughtering Marwood & had a bit of nous, they would notice this. Do you all really think that Soriano etc had no input ? They just suddenly blundered into the job in a state of total surprise & shock trying to rectify the mistakes of the evil Marwood ?
City have a plan. Not just for now, but for decades to come. If they feel Mancini is the right bloke to take that forward, he will be in charge for a long time. If they think Pep is a better choice, Bob will be gone.
Ted, PG, is a better manager than Bob, he has happier players he has proved he plays better football. He has not only been the most succesful manager, he was a Great player, rated as one of the best in his position his way would suit me I am a big fan. Love Bobby but he is all bussiness as the Monaco issue proved. Managers at this level move on and it is normal. Look at the special one at the biggest club in the world and looking after himself just as Bob did with Monaco. The top end clubs Bayern Madrid, now PSG to name a few will be openly changing managers all are in the loop it's normal. 5,6,7 mill a year is a nice salary for the worry.
Ted Hughes wrote:Hazy2 wrote:Ted Hughes wrote:Why is it that, when this subject crops up, a load of people turn into morons ? Fucking grow up.
It's a perfectly reasonable subject for discussion. Pep has just said he wants to be a manager in England.
I think Mancini has a better chance of achieving short term, continued success than Guardiola, as he has already done it & would have certainly done it again this season if he'd been allowed to sign RVP. The fact that the club had no enthusiasm for signing RVP should be an indication of the possible area where City, & Mancini could be at odds in their thinking.
If people weren't so busy happily slaughtering Marwood & had a bit of nous, they would notice this. Do you all really think that Soriano etc had no input ? They just suddenly blundered into the job in a state of total surprise & shock trying to rectify the mistakes of the evil Marwood ?
City have a plan. Not just for now, but for decades to come. If they feel Mancini is the right bloke to take that forward, he will be in charge for a long time. If they think Pep is a better choice, Bob will be gone.
Ted, PG, is a better manager than Bob, he has happier players he has proved he plays better football. He has not only been the most succesful manager, he was a Great player, rated as one of the best in his position his way would suit me I am a big fan. Love Bobby but he is all bussiness as the Monaco issue proved. Managers at this level move on and it is normal. Look at the special one at the biggest club in the world and looking after himself just as Bob did with Monaco. The top end clubs Bayern Madrid, now PSG to name a few will be openly changing managers all are in the loop it's normal. 5,6,7 mill a year is a nice salary for the worry.
There is no proof whatsoever that Pep can do what Mancini has done. There is also nothing to say that Mancini couldn't take over at Barca & win everything.
It is a very important & difficult decision which has a lot of pros & cons. Some people on here just laughing it away are being ridiculous but it's by no means cut & dried either way.
The ideal situation for City would be for Pep to go to Bayern for a few years whilst Bob continues. My gut feeling is that he will be in England though.
Peter Doherty (AGAIG) wrote:The powers that be at the club gave Mancini a 5 year contract in the full knowledge that Guardiola would be available next summer. That suggests that the job is Mancini's to lose and not Guardiola's to walk into if he feels like it.
Hazy2 wrote:Ted Hughes wrote:Hazy2 wrote:Ted Hughes wrote:Why is it that, when this subject crops up, a load of people turn into morons ? Fucking grow up.
It's a perfectly reasonable subject for discussion. Pep has just said he wants to be a manager in England.
I think Mancini has a better chance of achieving short term, continued success than Guardiola, as he has already done it & would have certainly done it again this season if he'd been allowed to sign RVP. The fact that the club had no enthusiasm for signing RVP should be an indication of the possible area where City, & Mancini could be at odds in their thinking.
If people weren't so busy happily slaughtering Marwood & had a bit of nous, they would notice this. Do you all really think that Soriano etc had no input ? They just suddenly blundered into the job in a state of total surprise & shock trying to rectify the mistakes of the evil Marwood ?
City have a plan. Not just for now, but for decades to come. If they feel Mancini is the right bloke to take that forward, he will be in charge for a long time. If they think Pep is a better choice, Bob will be gone.
Ted, PG, is a better manager than Bob, he has happier players he has proved he plays better football. He has not only been the most succesful manager, he was a Great player, rated as one of the best in his position his way would suit me I am a big fan. Love Bobby but he is all bussiness as the Monaco issue proved. Managers at this level move on and it is normal. Look at the special one at the biggest club in the world and looking after himself just as Bob did with Monaco. The top end clubs Bayern Madrid, now PSG to name a few will be openly changing managers all are in the loop it's normal. 5,6,7 mill a year is a nice salary for the worry.
There is no proof whatsoever that Pep can do what Mancini has done. There is also nothing to say that Mancini couldn't take over at Barca & win everything.
It is a very important & difficult decision which has a lot of pros & cons. Some people on here just laughing it away are being ridiculous but it's by no means cut & dried either way.
The ideal situation for City would be for Pep to go to Bayern for a few years whilst Bob continues. My gut feeling is that he will be in England though.
Mancini, has style of play which would not be suited to Barca, His next team coz they all move on will be Italy? or the Middle East, Bob, has done a great job,love him will he move us on in the way the owners want, I suggest that is where Pep comes in, he is a level above, any notion he inherited an all singing all dancing team ready to walk all over the world is just not true. He has players disco dancing to the small hours and taking the piss Deco Ronny, Eto not as much had become along with a very gulliable Messi were taking the piss Ryjkard had lost the dressing room which was split into two camps like Madrid now. What he has on his CV is better than anyone other than Jose who is a bad fit for us. If the Prem is his destination then MCFC have to get him IMHO, read the Book he worked wonders at Barca and there is more to that club than meets the eye. Manging that monster 1st job, is remarkable.
Ted Hughes wrote:Hazy2 wrote:Ted Hughes wrote:Hazy2 wrote:Ted Hughes wrote:Why is it that, when this subject crops up, a load of people turn into morons ? Fucking grow up.
It's a perfectly reasonable subject for discussion. Pep has just said he wants to be a manager in England.
I think Mancini has a better chance of achieving short term, continued success than Guardiola, as he has already done it & would have certainly done it again this season if he'd been allowed to sign RVP. The fact that the club had no enthusiasm for signing RVP should be an indication of the possible area where City, & Mancini could be at odds in their thinking.
If people weren't so busy happily slaughtering Marwood & had a bit of nous, they would notice this. Do you all really think that Soriano etc had no input ? They just suddenly blundered into the job in a state of total surprise & shock trying to rectify the mistakes of the evil Marwood ?
City have a plan. Not just for now, but for decades to come. If they feel Mancini is the right bloke to take that forward, he will be in charge for a long time. If they think Pep is a better choice, Bob will be gone.
Ted, PG, is a better manager than Bob, he has happier players he has proved he plays better football. He has not only been the most succesful manager, he was a Great player, rated as one of the best in his position his way would suit me I am a big fan. Love Bobby but he is all bussiness as the Monaco issue proved. Managers at this level move on and it is normal. Look at the special one at the biggest club in the world and looking after himself just as Bob did with Monaco. The top end clubs Bayern Madrid, now PSG to name a few will be openly changing managers all are in the loop it's normal. 5,6,7 mill a year is a nice salary for the worry.
There is no proof whatsoever that Pep can do what Mancini has done. There is also nothing to say that Mancini couldn't take over at Barca & win everything.
It is a very important & difficult decision which has a lot of pros & cons. Some people on here just laughing it away are being ridiculous but it's by no means cut & dried either way.
The ideal situation for City would be for Pep to go to Bayern for a few years whilst Bob continues. My gut feeling is that he will be in England though.
Mancini, has style of play which would not be suited to Barca, His next team coz they all move on will be Italy? or the Middle East, Bob, has done a great job,love him will he move us on in the way the owners want, I suggest that is where Pep comes in, he is a level above, any notion he inherited an all singing all dancing team ready to walk all over the world is just not true. He has players disco dancing to the small hours and taking the piss Deco Ronny, Eto not as much had become along with a very gulliable Messi were taking the piss Ryjkard had lost the dressing room which was split into two camps like Madrid now. What he has on his CV is better than anyone other than Jose who is a bad fit for us. If the Prem is his destination then MCFC have to get him IMHO, read the Book he worked wonders at Barca and there is more to that club than meets the eye. Manging that monster 1st job, is remarkable.
The manager doesn't get to choose the style of play at Barca, just to help organise it. I have no doubt personally that Mancini could do that.
However, Pep was one of the people who helped put that system in place, & that spreads throughout the whole club. That's what City will be wanting to do imo, & I'm not sure that Bob has a passion for that wheras Pep does, & that leaves Bob in danger imo as I have always believed that Khaldoon sees player development as our prime target.
Original Dub wrote:What's your opinion on the subject Beefy?
Ted Hughes wrote:Chinners wrote:Pep wouldn't just be new to managing in England, he would be new to managing any other club in the world other than Barcelona ... thats my concern tbh. I'm very happy for Mancini to cointinue at the moment no matter what happens this season (as long as we get a top 2 position obv.)
From a Premier League perspective it would be a huge gamble.
From an academy perspective, it would be a gamble to let him go to Utd, Arsenal or Chelsea, as he knows how it all works & is quite capable of putting at least a small spanner in the works regarding our plans.
Return to The Maine Football forum
Users browsing this forum: blues2win, carl_feedthegoat, Harry Dowd scored, Mase, Original Dub, PeterParker, Scatman and 450 guests