The mancityfans.net football forum

Obvious question. Muric was all the way, while Eddie, well, he is Eddie.

The kid. Doesn't make sense playing him all the way until the final then just dropping him. Especially after the penalty saves at Leicester.

Muric for me as well.

The last time we had this debate, it was just before that ill fated cup final against Wigan, that day BobbyManc chose Joe Hart ahead of Costel Pantilimon who played in every previous round.....

From his presser Pep says he's undecided, I seriously hope karma doesn't bite us in the arse a second time

go 4 up in 25 mins and bring muric on

I'm just buzzing Bravo isn't in the mix

Nigels Tackle wrote:go 4 up in 25 mins and bring muric on

go 4-0 up and take Muric off and play Ed up front ,
Bernardo in goals , he's brill.

Muric for me he deserves a final and there's plenty of silverware left for Eddie. It must be a bit shit being a goalie with game time being so scarce.

CBEM wrote:Muric for me he deserves a final and there's plenty of silverware left for Eddie. It must be a bit shit being a goalie with game time being so scarce.

I wouldn't have a problem with Muric in goal , hes actually pretty good to be fair -as long as we have Walker , Stones (Kompany) and laporte inf ront of him then we shouldn't worry.

carl_feedthegoat wrote:

CBEM wrote:Muric for me he deserves a final and there's plenty of silverware left for Eddie. It must be a bit shit being a goalie with game time being so scarce.

I wouldn't have a problem with Muric in goal , hes actually pretty good to be fair -as long as we have Walker , Stones (Kompany) and laporte inf ront of him then we shouldn't worry.

walker and kompany?!
were you on the vodka’s yesterday carl???

Nigels Tackle wrote:

carl_feedthegoat wrote:

CBEM wrote:Muric for me he deserves a final and there's plenty of silverware left for Eddie. It must be a bit shit being a goalie with game time being so scarce.

I wouldn't have a problem with Muric in goal , hes actually pretty good to be fair -as long as we have Walker , Stones (Kompany) and laporte inf ront of him then we shouldn't worry.

walker and kompany?!
were you on the vodka’s yesterday carl???

To be fair I did put that cunt in brackets as a back up plan - Walker has been ok up to now and he knows that one more fuck up and hes back on the bench.

I would play our best keeper in a cup final

john@staustell wrote:I would play our best keeper in a cup final

This.

Common sense trumps sentimentality

harveytravis wrote:

john@staustell wrote:I would play our best keeper in a cup final

This.

Common sense trumps sentimentality

So kids coming through will think "yeah, I may get chances in the Cup, but when we get to the final I'll be pied off so what's the point?"

Mase wrote:

harveytravis wrote:

john@staustell wrote:I would play our best keeper in a cup final

This.

Common sense trumps sentimentality

So kids coming through will think "yeah, I may get chances in the Cup, but when we get to the final I'll be pied off so what's the point?"

Depends how much you want to win really Mase. If the club is only here to jolly along the careers of lads who won't be here in 5 years or if the purpose is to win trophies for the fans - who are stuck here for life!

Not saying we wouldn't win with Muric but it's a bit of an arrogant gamble

john@staustell wrote:

Mase wrote:

harveytravis wrote:

john@staustell wrote:I would play our best keeper in a cup final

This.

Common sense trumps sentimentality

So kids coming through will think "yeah, I may get chances in the Cup, but when we get to the final I'll be pied off so what's the point?"

Depends how much you want to win really Mase. If the club is only here to jolly along the careers of lads who won't be here in 5 years or if the purpose is to win trophies for the fans - who are stuck here for life!

Not saying we wouldn't win with Muric but it's a bit of an arrogant gamble

Nothing arrogant about it, it's about doing what's right by the squad/team, it's about respect.

I do think he will play Muric.

But then with Pep, who knows?

muric 100%.

Easy, Muric.

Sentiment doesn't win trophies.
Ed please. If we don't we will loose a whole dimension to our game.