The mancityfans.net football forum

Surely Shay given ?

On goals on Sunday now. We had a good period of decent keepers. David James ended up quite good too.

Coton?

Bravo

john@staustell wrote:Coton?

Didn't he throw the ball in to his own net? Munich twat.

john@staustell wrote:Coton?

Would be my choice too

I think Hart could be considered.

Bit too young to realllyy remember coton but we were shit and went down ?

I think given was better than Hart, potentially when I started disliking Hart 1) his comments on loan which lead to 2) given being pushed out.

Given now is probably still better than bravo

Coton at the time should have been England's No.1 but was overlooked for Chris Woods & David Seaman - we had our highest finishes for many a year with him in the side.

Forgive his later transgressions as he arguably was the best keeper we've had in last 30 years.

Defo not given, he is average masked as great but has huge faults to his game, when playing for ireland hes better than at club level.

For me Hart, James, Scheimichal, Weaver in that order. I was too young to appreciate coton but i dont remeber him been shit.

This is a depressing thread all those saying they were too young to remember Tony f-ing Coton

Dunnylad wrote:This is a depressing thread all those saying they were too young to remember Tony f-ing Coton

It's more depressing for those too OLD to remember him, or anything else

It's multiple golden glove winner Joe Hart but hopefully will be Ederson.

David James was outstanding for us in the time he spent here. He's my pick.

The inconsistency of all these keepers makes it easier to pick season by season. Given was the only one I remember never been awful for a prolonged period.

It's coton closely followed by given them hart.
Best 3 in my time.

Quinn.

Foreverinbluedreams wrote:Quinn.

True, and he scored more than David James

Hutch's Shoulder wrote:

Foreverinbluedreams wrote:Quinn.

True, and he scored more than David James

Quinn really is a mystery.
Scored plenty of goals. Was well liked even saved a penalty yet he seems to dispise us now.

Dubciteh wrote:Defo not given, he is average masked as great but has huge faults to his game, when playing for ireland hes better than at club level.

For me Hart, James, Scheimichal, Weaver in that order. I was too young to appreciate coton but i dont remeber him been shit.

Seriously? Watch given back.used to pull world class saves every game. More than Hart and bravo did combined..

Schmixhael only did a year didn't he ?

James, agreed.

Weaver yes but at a lower level (obviously can't forget how important he was for where we are now) class lad too.

Shay Given for me