The mancityfans.net football forum

Apparently Schalke are close to agreeing a loan with option to buy. I wonder how much we'll get.

Saul Goodman wrote:Apparently Schalke are close to agreeing a loan with option to buy. I wonder how much we'll get.

probably...8 or 10 max i bet.

I don't like an "option" to buy. I want a commitment to buy. I'd expect that's the deal we're asking for as well.

cheers

Option is no good. Must be an obligation to buy, or otherwise we are likely to see him again next season.

Schalke only want a loan with an option which is not ideal. We are stuck with it though because no other club are interested, despite rumours about Milan.

With his injury record no club is going to take him without an "option" to buy.

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:With his injury record no club is going to take him without an "option" to buy.

It's not so much his injury record, it could be more about him being not very good.

I always forget how young he is. I think we will eventually get a decent pricee for him

Mikhail Chigorin wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:With his injury record no club is going to take him without an "option" to buy.

It's not so much his injury record, it could be more about him being not very good.

I thought he had a good first season (in the games i saw him play) and remember fans were singing his praises.

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:

Mikhail Chigorin wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:With his injury record no club is going to take him without an "option" to buy.

It's not so much his injury record, it could be more about him being not very good.

I thought he had a good first season (in the games i saw him play) and remember fans were singing his praises.

There has been a lot of divided discussion about Nastasic on this forum, with some very strong views held.

I'm of the opinion that he's not very good, however, that's just my biased opinion.

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:

Mikhail Chigorin wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:With his injury record no club is going to take him without an "option" to buy.

It's not so much his injury record, it could be more about him being not very good.

I thought he had a good first season (in the games i saw him play) and remember fans were singing his praises.

He was better than Lescott.

carl_feedthegoat wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:

Mikhail Chigorin wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:With his injury record no club is going to take him without an "option" to buy.

It's not so much his injury record, it could be more about him being not very good.

I thought he had a good first season (in the games i saw him play) and remember fans were singing his praises.

He was better than Lescott.

Only in the minds of the puddled.

Ted Hughes wrote:

carl_feedthegoat wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:

Mikhail Chigorin wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:With his injury record no club is going to take him without an "option" to buy.

It's not so much his injury record, it could be more about him being not very good.

I thought he had a good first season (in the games i saw him play) and remember fans were singing his praises.

He was better than Lescott.

Only in the minds of the puddled.

Back of the net.

I remember people saying he was the new Vidic hahahahahahaha!!

carl_feedthegoat wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:

Mikhail Chigorin wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:With his injury record no club is going to take him without an "option" to buy.

It's not so much his injury record, it could be more about him being not very good.

I thought he had a good first season (in the games i saw him play) and remember fans were singing his praises.

He was better than Lescott.

Yes he was, and most likely be a better player than Lesc ever was.

kennyboy wrote:

carl_feedthegoat wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:

Mikhail Chigorin wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:With his injury record no club is going to take him without an "option" to buy.

It's not so much his injury record, it could be more about him being not very good.

I thought he had a good first season (in the games i saw him play) and remember fans were singing his praises.

He was better than Lescott.

Yes he was, and most likely be a better player than Lesc ever was.

On playstation maybe.

And that's a big maybe!

kennyboy wrote:

carl_feedthegoat wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:

Mikhail Chigorin wrote:

Chippy_Tea_ wrote:With his injury record no club is going to take him without an "option" to buy.

It's not so much his injury record, it could be more about him being not very good.

I thought he had a good first season (in the games i saw him play) and remember fans were singing his praises.

He was better than Lescott.

Yes he was, and most likely be a better player than Lesc ever was.

This was absolutely proven not to be the case, so much so that you barely even mentioned him once it became generally accepted that he was shite, but now he's gone, you are going to pretend he was a success ?

I bet you have the hots for Savic as well.

This was absolutely proven not to be the case

Lol

Cocacolajojo wrote:

This was absolutely proven not to be the case

Lol

Not one single person was asking for Nastasic to be brought back in the side, even when everyone was injured, not one person who claimed he was the dogs' bollocks when he first came in, wanted him. He is now being kept out of the squad by Dedryk Boyata & nobody in the league wants to buy him.

How much more evidence is required ?

Not one single person was asking for Nastasic to be brought back in the side, even when everyone was injured, not one person who claimed he was the dogs' bollocks when he first came in, wanted him. He is now being kept out of the squad by Dedryk Boyata & nobody in the league wants to buy him.

How much more evidence is required ?

Evidence would only be relevant if you were interested in a discussion Ted. You aren't and you probably never have regarding Nasty. Lescott's gone, so is Nasty (soon anyway). We have Mangala. Everybody happy!

Cocacolajojo wrote:

Not one single person was asking for Nastasic to be brought back in the side, even when everyone was injured, not one person who claimed he was the dogs' bollocks when he first came in, wanted him. He is now being kept out of the squad by Dedryk Boyata & nobody in the league wants to buy him.

How much more evidence is required ?

Evidence would only be relevant if you were interested in a discussion Ted. You aren't and you probably never have regarding Nasty. Lescott's gone, so is Nasty (soon anyway). We have Mangala. Everybody happy!

I've always been available for discussion re Nasty, but neither you nor anyone else can give me one single example of anything he's ever done as a defender v anybody, ever.

People just trot out a mythical performance v Real Madrid, but can't point one single second of anything he did in the game. None of you can give one example of Nastasic doing anything in any game vs anybody. I've asked many times.