Brian kidd vs david platt

[MilnersJaw]

Who is better?

[Niall Quinns Discopants]

Which one os worse kind of rag twat should be name of this competition.

[Alioune DVToure]

Platt is better at looking like a root vegetable and Kidd is better at looking like he's trying to wrap his head around standard deviation.

Draw.

[PeterParker]

to be a bit offtopic, i wonder if they will stay in the dressing room with the new manager.

[sandman]

I like Kidd, he is a genuine football man who always talks sense when on camera, he knows the league better than almost anybody, he knows success more than most, he knows the club better than most, I would say he is our second most important non-playing staff member (after Les Chapman of course)

Pratt hated us before he came here, a leopard never changes his spots, I never forgave him for the vile hatred he spewed our way prior to his appointment.

[Mike J]

Which one os worse kind of rag twat should be name of this competition.

Christ you are a misery. Kidd is far from a twat.

Big fan of Kiddo, hope he stays at the club. Dont like Platt one little bit. Never have, never well. I suspect he will go wherever mancini goes.

[Bridge'srightfoot]

Which one os worse kind of rag twat should be name of this competition.

Christ you are a misery. Kidd is far from a twat.

Big fan of Kiddo, hope he stays at the club. Dont like Platt one little bit. Never have, never well. I suspect he will go wherever mancini goes.

He played for Rags and is therefore a despicable twat who at the very least should be executed.

[walshawblue]

Which one os worse kind of rag twat should be name of this competition.

Christ you are a misery. Kidd is far from a twat.

Big fan of Kiddo, hope he stays at the club. Dont like Platt one little bit. Never have, never well. I suspect he will go wherever mancini goes.

He played for Rags and is therefore a despicable twat who at the very least should be executed.

Did he not also play for us at some point.

[Scatman]

Which one os worse kind of rag twat should be name of this competition.

Christ you are a misery. Kidd is far from a twat.

Big fan of Kiddo, hope he stays at the club. Dont like Platt one little bit. Never have, never well. I suspect he will go wherever mancini goes.

He played for Rags and is therefore a despicable twat who at the very least should be executed.

Did he not also play for us at some point.

Let's get a Matt Busby stand

[Niall Quinns Discopants]

Which one os worse kind of rag twat should be name of this competition.

Christ you are a misery. Kidd is far from a twat.

Big fan of Kiddo, hope he stays at the club. Dont like Platt one little bit. Never have, never well. I suspect he will go wherever mancini goes.

He played for Rags and is therefore a despicable twat who at the very least should be executed.

Did he not also play for us at some point.

Let's get a Matt Busby stand

Correct.

[Peter Doherty (AGAIG)]

Which one os worse kind of rag twat should be name of this competition.

Christ you are a misery. Kidd is far from a twat.

Big fan of Kiddo, hope he stays at the club. Dont like Platt one little bit. Never have, never well. I suspect he will go wherever mancini goes.

He played for Rags and is therefore a despicable twat who at the very least should be executed.

Did he not also play for us at some point.

Yes he did, and with distinction.

[sandman]

Which one os worse kind of rag twat should be name of this competition.

Christ you are a misery. Kidd is far from a twat.

Big fan of Kiddo, hope he stays at the club. Dont like Platt one little bit. Never have, never well. I suspect he will go wherever mancini goes.

He played for Rags and is therefore a despicable twat who at the very least should be executed.

Did he not also play for us at some point.

I think 44 goals in 98 appearances showed enough commitment to City as a player, I have every confidence in him as an interim manager.

[Niall Quinns Discopants]

I still remember Kidd in rags touchline showing that one shaggy haired feller to give them "more punches" in derby. What was the name of that guy again..... ah yeah Mark Hughes.

A rag is a rag is a rag.

[Ted Hughes]

I still remember Kidd in rags touchline showing that one shaggy haired feller to give them "more punches" in derby. What was the name of that guy again..... ah yeah Mark Hughes.

A rag is a rag is a rag.

I remember him kicking the shit out of rags as a hero in blue.

[Niall Quinns Discopants]

I still remember Kidd in rags touchline showing that one shaggy haired feller to give them "more punches" in derby. What was the name of that guy again..... ah yeah Mark Hughes.

A rag is a rag is a rag.

I remember him kicking the shit out of rags as a hero in blue.

Do you remember him lifting that European Cup trophy as well?

A rag is a rag is a rag.

[Niall Quinns Discopants]

Also, now that we are remembering the career of Brian Kidd, anyone remember him managing Blackburn? LULZ.

[john@staustell]

Both are excellent coaches that couldn't do it as managers. KIdd scored a lot of goals for City. Our form raised when Platt joined Mancini as coach.

However I fancy both will have a long summer holiday somehow. Isn't that usually the way?

[Bridge'srightfoot]

I still remember Kidd in rags touchline showing that one shaggy haired feller to give them "more punches" in derby. What was the name of that guy again..... ah yeah Mark Hughes.

A rag is a rag is a rag.

I remember him kicking the shit out of rags as a hero in blue.

Do you remember him lifting that European Cup trophy as well?

A rag is a rag is a rag.

.
Tevez is also a former Rag yet he's played a massive part in our development as a club. In his first two seasons for us he was arguably one of the very best in the world. So he played for the Rags, so what? Did you not celebrate his goals for us, did you not sing his name when he was banging them in?
Just because someone has been associated with them doesn't mean they can't do a job for us aswell.
I'd like to hear your response without you resorting to childish insults or name calling.

[Goataldo]

Kidd is a local lad, a great character to have around the place, and has a wealth of football knowledge, not least about MCFC and a great football pegdigree. I like him, I'd love to have a beer with him - but then he's very likeable. V useful to keep on imho, even if only to ease transition for the new manager, like a handover I guess, with a view to proving his worth to the new boss.

Platt is a local rag, constantly looks like an egg travelling at speed, and doesn't seem to exactly exude charisma. Although I've chatted to him myself, and found him pleasant enough/reasonably personable, I wouldn't want to share a pint with him. He has footy pedigree, is Bob's mate, and speaks fluent Italian. He's like a bespoke Mancini right hand man.

So if you meant the question purely with a view to who should we keep, blatantly Kiddo, all the way. Platt will slither after Mancini like Renfield.

If you meant in a fight, I'd still back Kiddo. I'd even join in if we was losing.

[DoomMerchant]

Which one os worse kind of rag twat should be name of this competition.

Christ you are a misery. Kidd is far from a twat.

Big fan of Kiddo, hope he stays at the club. Dont like Platt one little bit. Never have, never well. I suspect he will go wherever mancini goes.

He played for Rags and is therefore a despicable twat who at the very least should be executed.

Did he not also play for us at some point.

Let's get a Matt Busby stand

that actually made me elle oh fuclin elle. Nice.