craigmcfc wrote:The fact that you can't appeal a booking if it is DEFINITELY incorrect, i.e. mistaken identity, is absolutely wrong. In this case though it's not a definite mistake, it was the top of the arm. I just tried to think if that had happened at the other end, would I have been happy if Birmingham had been allowed that goal and NO I wouldn't. Tough call but hard to argue against
MaineRoadMemories wrote:Can't appeal yellow cards.
Card was given for a handball.
Looked like he used the upper part of his arm to me and was a fair decision.
MaineRoadMemories wrote:Can't appeal yellow cards.
Card was given for a handball.
Looked like he used the upper part of his arm to me and was a fair decision.
If I remember correctly that one went in off his knob.Buffalo Soldier wrote:It reminded me of goater's at home against Wigan in the play off semi final. Have watched it a few times now and I still can't decide whether it was arm or shoulder.
King Kev wrote:If I remember correctly that one went in off his knob.Buffalo Soldier wrote:It reminded me of goater's at home against Wigan in the play off semi final. Have watched it a few times now and I still can't decide whether it was arm or shoulder.
King Kev wrote:If I remember correctly that one went in off his knob.Buffalo Soldier wrote:It reminded me of goater's at home against Wigan in the play off semi final. Have watched it a few times now and I still can't decide whether it was arm or shoulder.
Blue2 wrote:MaineRoadMemories wrote:Can't appeal yellow cards.
Card was given for a handball.
Looked like he used the upper part of his arm to me and was a fair decision.
Behave ,it was a perfectly good goal, even Trevor Francis agreed, so it must be a goal.
Return to The Maine Football forum
Users browsing this forum: Dubciteh, Google [Bot], Harry Dowd scored, Mase, ruralblue and 306 guests