the_georgian_genius wrote:I'll say this for this last time
WE HAVEN'T WON A FUCKING THING FOR 34 YEARS AND PEOPLE WANT TO START PLAYING KIDS IN A COMPETITION WE CAN WIN!!
Use your noggin!
Look you fucktards if you read the post rather than just answering your own questions.....you will see that it was a "hypothetical question" as to the quality of team we COULD put out
At no point did I say we should field a team of kids for the competition
Nor, if you look at the actual team...is it a team full of kids. I was musing as to the quality we had the capacity to put out.
However, if you look at the players deployed (say at Scunthorpe) during the last CC campaign you can see that Mancini is more than willing to throw some of the kids in. Sure Boyata was out of necessity in the games he played to some extent but I think it's obvious that Mancini will probably look to use the early rounds/weaker opposition to blood kids and give them proper game time with pressure.
I actually also fundamentally disagree that the approach taken by Arsene Wenger is the height of arrogance....they got to the final using kids....ie their kids are better than most teams first teams, or at least capable of outplaying them. That is exactly where we should be aiming. Sure loan deals are good for the development of youth prospects but ultimately we need to see if they can cut the mustard in a City shirt, deal with the inherent level of pressure of being a City player in the current circumstances and whether they actually can reproduce their talent in a proper competetive situation. The only way we can do this is by giving them the chance to do so, preferably whilst reducing the risk to them and us that they are not an instant success.
The early rounds of the cups are the place to do that. I agree that we want to win something but, used wisely, and within a suitably experienced team framework there is no reason why fielding the team I put up as an illustration would lead to us being knocked out. If a team like that (or other similar permutations.....with experienced back-up on the bench) can't dispose of a League 1 or 2 team then the players likely aren't the requisite quality to be at City.