Page 1 of 2
Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 5:51 pmby The Man In Blue
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/footbal ... 423124.stmSunderland defender Michael Turner given four-match ban
Sunderland defender Michael Turner has been handed a hefty four-match suspension after he was sent off against Manchester City on Saturday.
The 25-year-old was sent off in injury time of Sunderland's 4-3 defeat for catching City midfielder Gareth Barry with an elbow in an aerial challenge.
The Football Association added an extra game to the ban for wasting their time.
The FA has also asked Sunderland manager Steve Bruce to explain his comments after the game.
Bruce, who has until 31 December to respond to the FA's request, had asked referee Andre Mariner to look at Turner's red card again.
"I hope he [referee Andre Mariner] can have a look at it and he can see it was a shuddering challenge between two of the most honest professionals you are going to get.
"Michael Turner got higher. That is the only reason he has caught Gareth Barry.
"You have got to raise your elbows when you are jumping for a ball. I might as well tell my centre-half not to head it next week because he might get sent off.
"I hope the referee looks at it again. I doubt it, though."
The FA said Turner's appeal over the red card had had "no prospect of success" - hence its decision to add a game to the normal three-match suspension.
The ban rules Turner out of the three Premier League games against Everton, Sunderland and Bolton as well as the FA Cup tie against non-league Barrow.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 5:56 pmby Lee_Kinda
Good - he nearly killed bazza!
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 5:56 pmby Wonderwall
Sunderland defender Michael Turner has been handed a hefty four-match suspension after he was sent off against Manchester City on Saturday.
The 25-year-old was sent off in injury time of Sunderland's 4-3 defeat for catching City midfielder Gareth Barry with an elbow in an aerial challenge.
The Football Association added an extra game to the ban for wasting their time.
The FA has also asked Sunderland manager Steve Bruce to explain his comments after the game.
Bruce, who has until 31 December to respond to the FA's request, had asked referee Andre Mariner to look at Turner's red card again.
"I hope he [referee Andre Mariner] can have a look at it and he can see it was a shuddering challenge between two of the most honest professionals you are going to get.
"Michael Turner got higher. That is the only reason he has caught Gareth Barry.
"You have got to raise your elbows when you are jumping for a ball. I might as well tell my centre-half not to head it next week because he might get sent off.
"I hope the referee looks at it again. I doubt it, though."
The FA said Turner's appeal over the red card had had "no prospect of success" - hence its decision to add a game to the normal three-match suspension.
The ban rules Turner out of the three Premier League games against Everton, Sunderland and Bolton as well as the FA Cup tie against non-league Barrow.
old fat head will be going nuts now
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 5:57 pmby The Man In Blue
did anyone hear the elephant man after the game, saying the red card was "obscene"?
what a twat.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 6:00 pmby Wonderwall
The Man In Blue wrote:did anyone hear the elephant man after the game, saying the red card was "obscene"?
what a twat.
I understood what he meant and would feel a little aggrieved if it was one of ours. Turner never looked anywhere but the ball and was in the air before barry. It just looked like your average every day jump.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 6:04 pmby The Man In Blue
Wonderwall wrote:The Man In Blue wrote:did anyone hear the elephant man after the game, saying the red card was "obscene"?
what a twat.
I understood what he meant and would feel a little aggrieved if it was one of ours. Turner never looked anywhere but the ball and was in the air before barry. It just looked like your average every day jump.
theres a difference between saying something like "well, there was no intent there from turner so i feel it was a bit harsh", and labelling the decision to send turner off "obscene".
and he is still a twat.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 6:06 pmby Buffalo Soldier
Very harsh in my opinion, looked bad when I was at the game, but looking at the replays, you could see he never looked at anything other than the ball and there was no intent in it. I've seen some fucking ridiculous appeals that haven't been given an extar game for being 'frivolous'. Would be fucking fuming if it was the other way around.
Having said all that, it happened to one of the elephant mans players, so fuck him.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 6:23 pmby Kladze
Almost a none contact sport as it is .... not much further to go :(
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 6:35 pmby Kiss_The_Goat
Buffalo Soldier wrote:Very harsh in my opinion, looked bad when I was at the game, but looking at the replays, you could see he never looked at anything other than the ball and there was no intent in it. I've seen some fucking ridiculous appeals that haven't been given an extar game for being 'frivolous'. Would be fucking fuming if it was the other way around.
Having said all that, it happened to one of the elephant mans players, so fuck him.
Yeh I agree. 4 games seems totally over the top. Some of the shit that goes unnoticed or unpunished in the premiership every week and you get a Center Half being suspended for 4 games for going up and challenging for a header? I'd be livid if one of ours got 4 games for that.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 6:36 pmby irblinx
Buffalo Soldier wrote:Very harsh in my opinion, looked bad when I was at the game, but looking at the replays, you could see he never looked at anything other than the ball and there was no intent in it. I've seen some fucking ridiculous appeals that haven't been given an extar game for being 'frivolous'. Would be fucking fuming if it was the other way around.
Having said all that, it happened to one of the elephant mans players, so fuck him.
He lead with his elbow so it was a sending off, dangerous play, IMO but that's all. Still no need for Mr Potato Head to go off on one, he is gonna get hit for that I reckon, pretty much a personal attack on the ref if you listen to the whole interview
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 7:00 pmby walmai
Whenever I think about elbowing, I always remind myself that John Fashanu maimed Gary Mabbutt with his, so that he was effectively disfigured (months after recovering from the injury). And so I make Irblinx right. Yes, it mitigates the position to be able to show that the player was always looking at the ball, but it must be possible to make the challenge for the ball without swinging with force your elbow backwards even in the general direction of another player's face.
The extra game ban is fine by me. Steve Bruce after all is a nob.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 7:19 pmby avoidconfusion
Thought the red card was harsh, it wasn't intentional. To give him a 4 match ban now is ridiculous imho.
If anything the ref should have given a red to Nosworthy for his two footed studs up lunge at Kompany.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 7:22 pmby Buffalo Soldier
avoidconfusion wrote:Thought the red card was harsh, it wasn't intentional. To give him a 4 match ban now is ridiculous imho.
If anything the ref should have given a red to Nosworthy for his two footed studs up lunge at Kompany.
Agreed. Could have VERY easily broken Vinnie's ankle with that challenge, was definately a straight red.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 8:02 pmby Wonderwall
there is an age old argument that you need to jump using the arms as leverage to gain height. Turner was up before Barry so I think Turner was hard done by. However, I feel it is also very easy to jump in someone direction and lead with your elbow without actually looking at them. Top footballs usually have very good peripheral vision.
Its a difficult call and the FA should have just upheld the ban and not given it an extra game. That was just for bruce as the FA like to dick on anyone that is outspoken against them.
I have always hated the fact that the read was against our team and 4 other teams are going to benefit from it! I wish there was a way for us to benefit from it, like Sunderland playing with 10 men against us for the next 4 games that we meet.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 8:15 pmby edge275
4 match ban is very excessive. Some strange decisions going on this year.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 8:19 pmby Twobob
Really OTT for what is a foul but I'm sure it was nothing more than that
Bruce is a cock though - perhaps if he kept his fat gob shut they woudlnt have got this extra one?
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 8:21 pmby Nickyboy
from my seat at the game the challeng about 10 mins earlier by catermole on barry looked a lot worse - it wasn't even shown on motd.
its hard to tell from the replays if there was any intent by turner, but i remember at the time me and the people around me were going rabid about it - i agree with the consensus that the 3 match ban should of been upheld and no need for the extra match added
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Tue Dec 22, 2009 9:14 pmby bluej
Nickyboy wrote:from my seat at the game the challeng about 10 mins earlier by catermole on barry looked a lot worse - it wasn't even shown on motd.
its hard to tell from the replays if there was any intent by turner, but i remember at the time me and the people around me were going rabid about it - i agree with the consensus that the 3 match ban should of been upheld and no need for the extra match added
Yeah I agree with that. Funnily I didn't think there was much wrong with it until I saw the replays and it got worse the more times I watched it.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Wed Dec 23, 2009 12:02 amby ronk
I don't think Bruce should feel particularly hard done by. His teams appeal everything, dive, cheat and get away with lots of unpunished stuff. Other teams get red cards all the time, we've had a few more questionable ones recently.
Turner led with the elbow, maybe it wasn't deliberate but it was at least careless. Barry was jumping straight(ish) and he was the guy at an angle. If it had happened in reverse we would have been talking about how Barry was stupid for getting himself sent off.
Personally, I think he did know. Turner isn't someone I'd be inclined to give the benefit of the doubt. Proving intent is impossible, it's easy to elbow someone without looking at them. Especially if the intent is to put someone off with your elbow. It wasn't the only bad challenge of the game and sometimes refs give a little benefit it something happens once but really have no alternative if it happens again.
Re: Michael Turner - 4 Match Ban
Posted:
Wed Dec 23, 2009 12:02 amby dazby
I thought the elbow on Rocky was the harshest of all and deserved a red. The others were pale in comparison.