The mancityfans.net football forum

At 26!!

Jesus, apparently cant get over his ankle injury.

Glad we didnt sign him and puts Westham in more shit i guess, unless theres some sort of insurance in place? However I bet they didnt have a no claims bonus carried over when they bought him!

*Edit, it was our very own SWP who made the tackle during England training, that led to the injury thats made him retire, whoops. Bet SWP feels pretty bad for him

There are some silly rumours going around that he's considering legal action - against SWP - but I doubt that this is possible.

His ankle was affected by some form of Syndrome, further to the initial treatment for the injury on international duty. I can't quote chapter and verse, but some form of growth occurs occasionally on the bone, if it is mending itself further to trauma such as a break. This enlargement isn't malign in a conventional sense, but it makes high performance athleticism practically impossible and can lead to cartilage wastage.

In the end, he retired to avoid going around in a wheelchair in his 30-40's.

A great shame, because on his day he had the skills to pay the bills. I have resisted an all-too familiar foray onto Youtube.

I don't know about insurance; he won't be going short, I rather imagine.

Ho hum.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/footba ... lenge.html

This seems a bit light on any facts about the challenge from SWP on Ashton but has anyone ever made a successful claim against a player? I thought it was always against the club??

Didn't Haaland drop his claim against K(unt)eane on legal advice that he wouldn't win. Surely and accidental challenge in training is going to be much harder to make a claim than what was blatant assault that should have seen the twat serve time.

shame, Ashton was a good player and was linked with us more times than I care to remember. He certainly dumped us out of the FA cup single handedly.

I am sure he has a lovely amount of cash that any normal person would faint at.

Good luck Dean

PS: Wasnt he rumoured to be a city fan?

Ashton was a very good player IMHO,he always gave us a right going over.

Shame its over for him but like Walmai said he wont be on the dole any time soon.

Shame this i, he had alot of potencial to be a top striker in the Prem, that overhe ad kick at The Swamp about 2 years ago showed what he was capable off, not to mention knocking us out of the F.A Cup on his own in 2006.

Good luck to the lad.

walmai wrote:There are some silly rumours going around that he's considering legal action - against SWP - but I doubt that this is possible.

His ankle was affected by some form of Syndrome, further to the initial treatment for the injury on international duty. I can't quote chapter and verse, but some form of growth occurs occasionally on the bone, if it is mending itself further to trauma such as a break. This enlargement isn't malign in a conventional sense, but it makes high performance athleticism practically impossible and can lead to cartilage wastage.

In the end, he retired to avoid going around in a wheelchair in his 30-40's.

A great shame, because on his day he had the skills to pay the bills. I have resisted an all-too familiar foray onto Youtube.

I don't know about insurance; he won't be going short, I rather imagine.

Ho hum.

gutted for Hammers fans really...he had so much promise.

About that little Hines kid? How much for him?

cheers

Quality player, fine centre forward, and a blue ?

I'm sorry to hear that, he's still very young and to have to end his career this way is a pity.

Bad news walmai, Quality player when he was fit and on form. I remember desperately wanting us to sign him under Pearce when he scored against us for Norwich. Then the bastard knocked us out of the FA Cup quarters for you lot ! :-)

DoomMerchant wrote:

walmai wrote:There are some silly rumours going around that he's considering legal action - against SWP - but I doubt that this is possible.

His ankle was affected by some form of Syndrome, further to the initial treatment for the injury on international duty. I can't quote chapter and verse, but some form of growth occurs occasionally on the bone, if it is mending itself further to trauma such as a break. This enlargement isn't malign in a conventional sense, but it makes high performance athleticism practically impossible and can lead to cartilage wastage.

In the end, he retired to avoid going around in a wheelchair in his 30-40's.

A great shame, because on his day he had the skills to pay the bills. I have resisted an all-too familiar foray onto Youtube.

I don't know about insurance; he won't be going short, I rather imagine.

Ho hum.

gutted for Hammers fans really...he had so much promise.

About that little Hines kid? How much for him?

cheers

Hines? Might go all the way, although clearly needs to bulk up a bit before moving on to a better club!

Quality player.What a shame his career was cut so short.The Prem and WHU will surely miss his class :-(

walmai wrote:Hines? Might go all the way, although clearly needs to bulk up a bit before moving on to a better club!

Let's hope he's not another Sturridge in the making

shawzy wrote:Quality player.What a shame his career was cut so short.The Prem and WHU will surely miss his class :-(

Completely forgot to put something similar in my reply, couldn't agree more. Likeable guy who got dealt a bad hand of injuries, let's hope that Johnno is not the next English player to be forced out of the game early

walmai wrote:His ankle was affected by some form of Syndrome, further to the initial treatment for the injury on international duty. I can't quote chapter and verse, but some form of growth occurs occasionally on the bone, if it is mending itself further to trauma such as a break. This enlargement isn't malign in a conventional sense, but it makes high performance athleticism practically impossible and can lead to cartilage wastage.

Didn't Bischoff have a similar problem.

Poor Dean, over when he'd just started to get going.

Wonderwall wrote:shame, Ashton was a good player and was linked with us more times than I care to remember. He certainly dumped us out of the FA cup single handedly.

I am sure he has a lovely amount of cash that any normal person would faint at.

Good luck Dean

PS: Wasnt he rumoured to be a city fan?

He was a scum fan. He was interviewed by the local crewe paper when he played for the alex, said it was his lifes dream to play for em.

Met him a couple of times in local pubs and clubs. His opinion of himself was, shall we say, overwelming.

Walmai what happened to that promising black kid you got from Italy?! Didn't you get rid after just a few months?

That is unfortunate for Dean Ashton, he was a quality player and it is bad that injuries caused him to retire...

I seem to remember Ben Collet (rags) took legal action against a boro player for a challenge that effectively ended his career, he ended up in season 1 of A-league playing for NZ knights.

Ashton has played 40 games since SWP injured him. I understand that the break could have caused a degenerative condition in the bone but it would be difficult to argue that this ended his career when he has played so many games since the incident. It's not like the injuries to Bell and Lake where they played a few games but kept breaking down again.

The other thing to consider is that West Ham gave him a new 5 year contract last year. Surely they would have given him a medical examination before committing to such an investment?

It's a shame he has had to retire but I feel confident that he is financially stable and doesn't need to go making crazy claims of compensation against SWP, The FA or anybody else. The only people he should be claiming from are his insurers.

City1970 wrote:

Wonderwall wrote:shame, Ashton was a good player and was linked with us more times than I care to remember. He certainly dumped us out of the FA cup single handedly.

I am sure he has a lovely amount of cash that any normal person would faint at.

Good luck Dean

PS: Wasnt he rumoured to be a city fan?

He was a scum fan. He was interviewed by the local crewe paper when he played for the alex, said it was his lifes dream to play for em.

Met him a couple of times in local pubs and clubs. His opinion of himself was, shall we say, overwelming.

thanks for that mate, I never knew he supported them......fuck him