The mancityfans.net football forum

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 5:48 am**

dunney has started to slag city off, about him and his testimonial. now he says he was pushed out and he didnt want to go.now everyone[apart from a few]have give good luck msgs on a few forums and then he starts benn bitchy about it. to be honest, he was not up to the job, we are going places now and sometimes dunney would do something that would slow us down. and hes slagging us for not giving him a testimonial, and him losing pounds because of it. mind now hes gone to the papers with his story he can get some money back. i will still give him a cheer when he comes back, but dunney wind your neck in please

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 5:59 am**

Just read about it on here http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/sp ... unces.html
Hes takin the piss

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 6:13 am**

If true it's a shitty way to proceed though. I hope it's not true (which means I hope Dunny's lying, which sucks too).

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 7:04 am**

If what Dunney says is true, and to be honest I would not know why he would be lieing, then this leaves a really sour taste after all the good things Cook, Hughes and Khaldoon have done.

I didn't have a single thing to criticize about them yet I thought they way they did things, behaved and presented themselves in the transfer window was remarkable... but this really does leave a bad taste now.

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 7:15 am**

The way I read it was...

We players get our own way on everything and Cookie didn't understand this, they put the club before ME, the player, and this is because they don't understand how football works.

About time someone had their priorities right.

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 7:21 am**

It takes a very strong Manager to tell a player who has won player of the year so often and been an excellent servant of the club that he is no longer needed. It would have been far easier for Hughes and Co to allow Dunne to stay as a squad player, but he did not fit into the plans, we need to devlop our youth more than hold on to our past

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 7:23 am**

If the information in the Sun article is correct we reduced the asking price so the deal could progress AND gave him a loyalty payment of £600,000. We truly are an evil club arent we? Some players need to keep their mouths shut sometimes.

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 7:27 am**

Nine years of fantastic wages, standing by him through a few off the field issues and four player of the year awards. And now he's complaining that he was hard done to. He's just got a £550k pay off from City for a start - how long will it take most of us to earn that sort of money? He could easily have been sacked about 7 years ago and I don't think he'd have been doing that well since.

How about "Loved my time at City. I would have loved to have stayed, but the club wanted to move me on. A big thank you to everyone there, especially the fans for voting me player of the season four times. I'm now a Villa player and I'm looking forward to doing my best for them, starting at..."

Kind of says the same thing without the "life isn't fair" bleating.

Won't go as far as booing him, but he ain't getting a clap when he returns. Think it would be quite funny if his name was read out to complete silence.

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 7:32 am**

Maybe this mard arse whinging is why he was sold.

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 7:42 am**

And more in the daily fail:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footba ... l?ITO=1490

Dunne hits out at 'back-stabber' Cook over £5m City exit

By COLIN YOUNG

Last updated at 12:47 AM on 04th September 2009

* Comments (0)
* Add to My Stories

Kicked out: Dunne

Kicked out: Dunne says he was sold against his will

Richard Dunne has accused Manchester City of deceit in an incredible attack on the Barclays Premier League's big spenders.

Dunne, who began the season as captain at Eastlands but was sold to Aston Villa for £5million this week, says he was forced out by the club's executive chairman Garry Cook, who he claims 'doesn't understand football'.

Dunne said: 'All he wants is big-money players. He doesn't understand the core loyalty of the club and where it begins.

'For him I was probably a bit of a nuisance. I found out things that were going on behind my back and I wouldn't speak to him. Every time I came around he probably felt a bit uncomfortable.

'The manager (Mark Hughes) is very quiet, he does his own thing and I spoke with him a few times through the summer about what was going on. He was of the opinion that City needed two players for every position and that was the way the squad was going to work.

'The last time I spoke to him was in Africa after I had found out some other stuff. I said, "Where do I lie in the whole thing?" and he said they were trying to sign players and I would be part of his squad and I could fight for my place.

'He said I was still the captain and even last week he said to me he would rather I stayed but he was told we needed to get money in. I don't think it was his decision.

'They told me they have a certain amount of money they have to recoup each season to make things look better on the books. I could understand if I was being sold for £200m, it might make sense, but it was a bit strange really.

'It just needed people to be honest with me. I was getting phone calls from people saying Garry Cook (pictured) was trying to sell me behind my back, two months after me going to him and saying if he has any problems to come and deal with me. I'm disappointed with people who say one thing and then do the other.

'I'm not going to cry just because the club wanted to sell me - just don't do it behind my back.'

City spent £120m in their summer spree, adding centre backs Joleon Lescott and Kolo Toure to replace Dunne, as well as Carlos Tevez, Emmanuel Adebayor, Roque Santa Cruz and Gareth Barry.
Tough call: Richard Dunne will make his Villa debut in the Birmingham derby

Tough call: Richard Dunne will make his Villa debut in the Birmingham derby on his return from Ireland duty

Dunne, now preparing for Ireland'sWorld Cup qualifier in Cyprus on Saturday, added: 'City have just signed Joleon Lescott and he's getting dog's abuse for being disloyal and breaking a contract he signed at Everton a year ago. But City have just done the exact same to me. It's not me who asked to leave.

'I would quite happily have stayed there and been part of the squad and fought for my place. I have been loyal to them for a long time but it was their decision to cancel a four-year contract.

'It seems to me the contract they gave me last year was just pointless. Twelve months down the line, when it doesn't suit them anymore, they just put it in the bin and say, "Off you go".'

At least Dunne is convinced Villa will be competing with City for a place in the top four and that their stability under Martin O'Neill will give his new club the edge.

The 29-year-old Dubliner, who will make his Villa debut in the Birmingham derby on his return from Ireland duty, added: 'It softens the blow. I'm moving to a club which has similar ambitions. Obviously, they don't have the financial backing of Man City but we have a squad as good as most in the league.

'It is difficult at City because of the amount of players that have come in. So far everything has gelled really well and the results have been really good, but when it gets difficult there's not really the bonding in the dressing room.

'Villa's squad is young and have been together a while and they have the confidence of last year, when they were fourth for a long time.'

Dunne's point about the City superstar culture was highlighted yesterday as Robinho admitted he put country before club by asking to sit out Sunday's 1-0 win at Portsmouth.

Robinho was desperate to be fit for Brazil's trip to Argentina tomorrow, when his country can put their great rivals in serious danger of missing next summer's World Cup. 'I asked to not play because I had pains in the ankle, but especially because Brazil v Argentina is more important,' he said.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footba ... z0Q7aqab64

Honestly I don't believe he was good enough anymore for the first team but stll... if this is true, this isn't really nice of the club.

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 8:01 am**

avoidconfusion wrote:And more in the daily fail:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footba ... l?ITO=1490

Dunne hits out at 'back-stabber' Cook over £5m City exit

By COLIN YOUNG

Last updated at 12:47 AM on 04th September 2009

* Comments (0)
* Add to My Stories

Kicked out: Dunne

Kicked out: Dunne says he was sold against his will

Richard Dunne has accused Manchester City of deceit in an incredible attack on the Barclays Premier League's big spenders.

Dunne, who began the season as captain at Eastlands but was sold to Aston Villa for £5million this week, says he was forced out by the club's executive chairman Garry Cook, who he claims 'doesn't understand football'.

Dunne said: 'All he wants is big-money players. He doesn't understand the core loyalty of the club and where it begins.

'For him I was probably a bit of a nuisance. I found out things that were going on behind my back and I wouldn't speak to him. Every time I came around he probably felt a bit uncomfortable.

'The manager (Mark Hughes) is very quiet, he does his own thing and I spoke with him a few times through the summer about what was going on. He was of the opinion that City needed two players for every position and that was the way the squad was going to work.

'The last time I spoke to him was in Africa after I had found out some other stuff. I said, "Where do I lie in the whole thing?" and he said they were trying to sign players and I would be part of his squad and I could fight for my place.

'He said I was still the captain and even last week he said to me he would rather I stayed but he was told we needed to get money in. I don't think it was his decision.

'They told me they have a certain amount of money they have to recoup each season to make things look better on the books. I could understand if I was being sold for £200m, it might make sense, but it was a bit strange really.

'It just needed people to be honest with me. I was getting phone calls from people saying Garry Cook (pictured) was trying to sell me behind my back, two months after me going to him and saying if he has any problems to come and deal with me. I'm disappointed with people who say one thing and then do the other.

'I'm not going to cry just because the club wanted to sell me - just don't do it behind my back.'

City spent £120m in their summer spree, adding centre backs Joleon Lescott and Kolo Toure to replace Dunne, as well as Carlos Tevez, Emmanuel Adebayor, Roque Santa Cruz and Gareth Barry.
Tough call: Richard Dunne will make his Villa debut in the Birmingham derby

Tough call: Richard Dunne will make his Villa debut in the Birmingham derby on his return from Ireland duty

Dunne, now preparing for Ireland'sWorld Cup qualifier in Cyprus on Saturday, added: 'City have just signed Joleon Lescott and he's getting dog's abuse for being disloyal and breaking a contract he signed at Everton a year ago. But City have just done the exact same to me. It's not me who asked to leave.

'I would quite happily have stayed there and been part of the squad and fought for my place. I have been loyal to them for a long time but it was their decision to cancel a four-year contract.

'It seems to me the contract they gave me last year was just pointless. Twelve months down the line, when it doesn't suit them anymore, they just put it in the bin and say, "Off you go".'

At least Dunne is convinced Villa will be competing with City for a place in the top four and that their stability under Martin O'Neill will give his new club the edge.

The 29-year-old Dubliner, who will make his Villa debut in the Birmingham derby on his return from Ireland duty, added: 'It softens the blow. I'm moving to a club which has similar ambitions. Obviously, they don't have the financial backing of Man City but we have a squad as good as most in the league.

'It is difficult at City because of the amount of players that have come in. So far everything has gelled really well and the results have been really good, but when it gets difficult there's not really the bonding in the dressing room.

'Villa's squad is young and have been together a while and they have the confidence of last year, when they were fourth for a long time.'

Dunne's point about the City superstar culture was highlighted yesterday as Robinho admitted he put country before club by asking to sit out Sunday's 1-0 win at Portsmouth.

Robinho was desperate to be fit for Brazil's trip to Argentina tomorrow, when his country can put their great rivals in serious danger of missing next summer's World Cup. 'I asked to not play because I had pains in the ankle, but especially because Brazil v Argentina is more important,' he said.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footba ... z0Q7aqab64

Honestly I don't believe he was good enough anymore for the first team but stll... if this is true, this isn't really nice of the club.

not much of a surprise they wanted rid of him then

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 8:14 am**

Not going to say anything that hasn't been said before or that won't be said again.

But he has a fucking cheek. He got a MASSIVE payoff we had zero obligation to give.

We stuck by him when he was a pissed up mess and clearly guilty of gross misconduct and ripe for the sack

We kept him as team captain and as a starter last season in the face of poor performances, losing us key points and matches and terrible leadership (esp when we had much better candidates for the armband already on the staff)

We eventually probably did "force" him out (nastily forcing him to a club who finished above us on a paltry 75k per week) BUT only because he is either too thick, stubborn or arrogant to realise that he was hugely not good enough to play in our new team.

We owe Richard Dunne fuck all.

Despite the fact that I have long wanted him sold I did actually feel a pang of sadness when he went.

That's all gone now. Hope his Villa career is a disaster the big clumsy inept shit

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 8:17 am**

The truth I have decided to make up and believe is that Dunney was told players are going to be coming in, you can stay and fight, take your chance when someone is injured or suspended, but we cant sign a 24 million pound defender and play him on the bench.

So

If your not up for it, Villa have made an offer, youll probably get regular football, whereas here, you wont at the moment, what do you want to do?

"Ill leave, thanks for the memories"

"Thank you too Richard, heres an envelope with a big thank you, be on your way then, close the door on your way out."

We are happy, he is happy, everybodys happy, bye bye

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 8:42 am**

Core truth of the matter is that a side that has aspirations of finishing in the top 4 in the Premier league needs a better quality centre half than Dunne at the heart of the defence, fact (as CARL would rightly point out)

Sentiment gets you absolutely nowhere in top level football.

If Dunne cannot see this then that is his problem, but it is certainly be time for him to shut his big fat gob and stop throwing barbs at a team that paid him handsomely for 9 years, from which he trousered a large pay-off and also stood by him when he was rolling up at the training ground half-cut.

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 8:50 am**

I think the problem is that Dunne was sacked effectively. At this point he is very upset and has opened up about the things that annoyed him during his time. But the fact he was just another employee meant he ignored all these "problems" enough to get on with his job. When other players have been shunted out he hasn't said a thing.
He's just acting like a regular human being.

Now here's the problem for me - he's secured a new job and redundancy payment in the same week. With numbers which are astronomical to regular people but ordinary to him. I wish we all could be so lucky.

No company will look good when the sacked individual talks about the people that fired them. No one EVER leaves on perfect terms. My disappointment with City is the lack of confidentiality clause to his departure. As he was club captain I would expect a restrictive covenant as part of his final payment limiting what is revealed about the workings of the club.

As for needing the money; I think that is true. City have sold Dunne because he was demoted to fourth choice and would cost 20 million in wages over the term of his contract. That is an excessive figure for a reserve team player (not always on the bench). Regardless of how rich we are as a business Cook has to justify the wage bill for each employee. If they are in the starting 11 it's easy. If they are injured it's still easy. Demoted to the bench, a little harder. Demoted to the reserves pretty damn hard.

Dunne is turning 30, was on a contract for 20 million and would work mostly at reserve team level. Limited resale value in January. No resale value next summer.
I personally wanted him to stay but I am just a fan, and I am supposed to be emotional about the club. Cook is doing his job, he has less room to be emotional. But I damn well expect that next time the contracts and severance packages of players are presented they explicitly talk about players media obligations and what is NOT permitted without club approval. If Cook doesn't get this sorted then I will be very annoyed with him. Whistleblowing is fine for breaches of law not because of tantrums or feeling slighted.

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 8:54 am**

The tone in this thread stinks, Dunnie never had a reputation of slagging off City, the management or anything about the Club so this outburst is out of character. Personnally I have had enough of this site, I love City for many reasons but I feel a lot of our fans are getting their heads stuck up their arse, particularly on this site....time to leave for me too...the lunatics are taking over the asylum.

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 9:08 am**

What's so hard about giving him a testemonial. He deserves it, it would make the club look good, get the likes of the Goat and Ali B back and maybe raise money for charity.... Everyone's a winner....

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 9:09 am**

completely agree with trout man,if you take your blinkers off and read the article correctly dunnie aint talkin about money but how he has been treated by the club he loves,players like dunnie who would shed blood for the club been fucked out when they want to stay and fight for his place to bring in players who are only after a big pay packet shows how shallow this club and fans are.

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 9:17 am**

dunne maybe earned,. what, 7, 8, 9 million from us? actually, a lot more, his 60k a week for the past 2 seasons is 6 mill alone.

did he think he'd be in this team, i mean, seriously? he has been a good servant and villa are welcome to his declining days. he'll be shocking in a year or two.

Posted: **Fri Sep 04, 2009 9:28 am**

ant london wrote:Not going to say anything that hasn't been said before or that won't be said again.

But he has a fucking cheek. He got a MASSIVE payoff we had zero obligation to give.

We stuck by him when he was a pissed up mess and clearly guilty of gross misconduct and ripe for the sack

We kept him as team captain and as a starter last season in the face of poor performances, losing us key points and matches and terrible leadership (esp when we had much better candidates for the armband already on the staff)

We eventually probably did "force" him out (nastily forcing him to a club who finished above us on a paltry 75k per week) BUT only because he is either too thick, stubborn or arrogant to realise that he was hugely not good enough to play in our new team.

We owe Richard Dunne fuck all.

Despite the fact that I have long wanted him sold I did actually feel a pang of sadness when he went.

That's all gone now. Hope his Villa career is a disaster the big clumsy inept shit

Haha,....best post i've seen re. Dunne so far

The mancityfans.net football forum

oh dunney

oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney

Re: oh dunney